November 1, 2026 District Letter

Dear Neighbors:

I hope you had a scary and fun Halloween. I encourage you (if you have not already) to exercise your right to vote this week in an election whose outcome will shape our City, State and national governments. In this letter, I will discuss a Rhode Island federal court decision that illustrates the ongoing national struggle over the rule of law.

A. The Sanchez v. Almond Decision

Last week, in a Decision by Chief Judge McConnell, the Rhode Island federal district court issued summary judgment in favor of Miguel Sanchez in his wrongful termination case against the State of Rhode Island. In his lawsuit, Councilman Sanchez asserted he was terminated due to Twitter (or “X”) comments he posted in his capacity as a Councilman in opposition to Israel’s response to Hamas’s terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians. In his Decision, Judge McConnell ruled that Councilman Sanchez was entitled to summary judgment on his claim the State’s termination of his employment was an illegal violation of his Constitutional right to free speech.

B. Lessons to Learn

1. A First Amendment Victory

On its surface, Judge McConnell’s decision was a victory for the First Amendment. If we look more closely, we can also see that it is a victory for the principle of an independent judiciary and the rule of law.

2. Elon Musk’s Role and Response to the Sanchez Case Outcome

To understand why, we should look at the role of Elon Musk in this case and other ones. Mr. Sanchez’s lead attorney was Gene Schaerr, an excellent Washington D.C. attorney whom I admired when we were law school classmates. As described in this Bloomberg Law article, in 2023 Mr. Musk announced on X that “If you were unfairly treated by your employer due to posting or liking something on this platform, we will fund your legal bill,” and since then he has hired Mr. Schaerr to represent terminated employees, including Councilman Sanchez. These employees have had some big court victories, such as when a court ordered the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign to rescind a disciplinary action against a student because the University disapproved of his posts on X. Mr. Musk issued a celebratory Tweet (“Justice has prevailed! X has successfully fought for its user’s right to free speech”) after that case (also brought by Mr. Schaerr) was decided. In contrast, Mr. Musk has not mentioned Councilman Sanchez’s victory in any of the more than 73 messages Mr. Musk has posted on X since the Rhode Island federal court decision.

3. Mr. Musk’s Previous Attack on Rhode Island’s Federal Court

This is a good time to remember the last time Mr. Musk posted on X concerning the Rhode Island federal court in general and Judge McConnell in particular. In February, 2025, Judge McConnell issued a temporary restraining order to prevent the implementation of a funding freeze directed by Mr. Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency (“DOGE”). In response, as quoted in this WPRI Report, Mr. Musk wrote: “Impeach this activist posing as a judge! Such a person does great discredit to the American justice system.” He later added, “Impeach this pseudo-jurist!!” Musk’s attack and those of others led to death threats against Judge McConnell and the doxxing of his daughter.

4. Explaining Mr. Musk’s Post-Victory Reticence

We cannot know what Mr. Musk was thinking then or now. Perhaps Mr. Musk is embarrassed by his previous attacks on the judge who decided in favor of X in Councilman Sanchez’s case, which now appear misguided, and which would make a current celebration appear hypocritical. Perhaps he is reluctant to celebrate X’s court victory because he still actually thinks the judge who decided the case is a “pseudo-jurist.” In any event, I suspect that if Judge McConnell were asked specifically about this pair of case decisions and chose to answer, he would merely say (in my opinion credibly) he was doing his job to decide both cases on their legal merits without regard to politics.

C. Conclusion

We cannot deny that in recent decades the process for selecting federal judges has become more political than before, and that the United States Supreme Court has missed opportunities to keep the Trump administration within accepted legal guardrails. With that said, there are many examples of judges appointed by Republican Presidents who have ruled against the Trump administration. Despite the efforts of President Trump and Elon Musk to undermine judicial independence and the rule of law in our country, I believe their efforts will be impeded (and I hope ultimately limited) by the norms of our country’s legal culture and tradition.